AnsweredAssumed Answered

Record Import via XML doesn't work with HTTPS/SSL

Question asked by JohnDCCIU on Jun 17, 2011
Latest reply on Sep 3, 2012 by JohnDCCIU


Record Import via XML doesn't work with HTTPS/SSL


FileMaker Pro



Operating system version

Mac OS X 10.6.7

Description of the issue

The Import Records function for XML data fails if either URL (XML or XSL) is an HTTPS (SSL) URL.  This is a serious and strange limitation, since much XML data is confidential and must be protected via SSL.

Furthermore, this serious and non-obvious limitation is not noted explicitly anywhere in the documentation or online help that I can find.

Even worse, if you try to use an HTTPS URL, FileMaker returns a generic and useless "unable to open primary document entity" error, rather than a useful "this function does not currently support HTTPS/SSL URLs".

Not sure if this is a bug or just a design flaw, but it needs to be fixed to use SSL/HTTPS's a necessity and there's no good reason not to support it.

To ensure that this was actually the issue causing this problem, I took an identical XML file and put it on my local webserver in a straight HTTP site:  it worked fine.  I then moved the XML file to our HTTPS site and it broke the Import Records function.

Steps to reproduce the problem

Try to use an HTTPS URL for XML import (either manually via File/Import Records or via the Import Records script step) and watch it fail with a non-specific "unable to open primary document entity" error.

Expected result

HTTPS/SSL URLs SHOULD work in this context

Actual result

HTTPS/SSL URLs DO NOT WORK in this context

Exact text of any error message(s) that appear

"unable to open primary document entity"

Configuration information



On Mac OS X, you can script a shell-based "curl" statement to download the XML via HTTPS and save it to a local file on disk, then use that local file for the Import Records.  Doing that is a pain in the neck, breaks cross-platform compatibility, and it shouldn't be required.

I'm not sure how you'd work around it on Windows.