1 Reply Latest reply on Sep 10, 2010 2:11 PM by cwhorton_1

    Should We Put Server 11 on Our X-Serve?

    PaulCook

      Title

      Should We Put Server 11 on Our X-Serve?

      Your post

      Does FileMaker Server 11 work OK on a machine that is doing some file sharing and is an Open Directory master?


      We were going to put FileMaker 11 server on our X-Serve. But we are getting mixed messages as to if we should do that, or if it is even supported.


      We noticed the following warning on on the "Before You Begin" pane of the installer dialog for FileMaker Server 11.


      "Install FileMaker Server on a dedicated machine reserved for use as a database server. Do not use an email, print or network file server."

      But page 11, of the The FileMaker Server Getting Started document is quite a bit more relaxed in its requirements. It doesn't explicitly prohibit any of the above, it just warns you that, "Other processor-intensive software or heavy network traffic on the same machine will cause FileMaker Server to run more slowly and degrade the performance…" 


      This would seem to at best be an unclear situation. Did anyone else try this and how did it work?
      Our X-Serve is a Xserve (Early 2008) Quad-Core Intel Xeon 5400 series processor, with RAID 5 drive configuration. Specifications here: http://support.apple.com/kb/SP10

      *************

      Thanks, the real concern was if there were some kind of incompatibility if those services were to be enabled. 

        • 1. Re: Should We Put Server 11 on Our X-Serve?
          cwhorton_1

          Over the years, we have installed FileMaker Server in many different version (including 11) on our servers and our clients' servers.  There is nothing inheritly wrong with having multiple services (FileMaker, web, file sharing, print serving) on the same computer.  It really all comes down to the hardware you have (memory being most important) and the workload you put on it.

          Not knowing how much of a workload you currently place on your server I can't answer this question easily for you.  My advice would be just to try it and if you notice degradation of services then dedicate hardware to FileMaker.

          Carl Horton
          President
          Austin Michael Internet Solutions
          FileMaker Hosting Services