6 Replies Latest reply on Mar 15, 2012 7:02 AM by timwhisenant

    Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!

    smoothie

      Hi All;

       

      I'm getting very annoyed with what appears to be a really bad "aggressive default" in FM11 Pro. In a Window that is maximized with elements that are stretched to fit the screen, when I execute a script to open a related record in a new window, or tell it to open a new window and goto a layout in the new window, the original window automatically resizes without being told to, to its unstreched dimensions. I've searched in vain for a setting to stop this behaviour. Am I missing something? I seriously don't want windows spontaneously resizing themselves unless I tell them to, as it makes for a very unappealing user experience.

       

      Please shine the light if there's a solution to this nasty behaviour.

       

      Thanks!

        • 1. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
          Malcolm

          If you are running on any flavour of windows this is the expected behaviour. Nasty, isn't it. The work-around is to size the windows to fill the screen without putting them into the maximised state.

           

          Malcolm

          • 2. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
            smoothie

            I see other posts now that relate to this issue.  Some blame Windows as the culprit.  As a longtime Windows developer in other environments, I can tell you that this isn't the case.  Its a bug in FileMaker.  Windows don't magically resize themselves in Windows unless your code tells them to.

            • 3. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
              BruceHerbach

              HI,

               

              I believe the issue is that FileMaker only allows 1 window to be Maximized.  Opening another window will tell the new window to be Maximized because the parent window was.  This will resize the parent window. 

               

              I get around this by haveing windows be sized when they open as part of the script and have the window be a few pixels smaller then maximum.  If the window is just a little smaller then Max, it won't trigger the resizing you are seeing.   Check out the Get functions that pertain to Screen.  They will let you determine the screen size and come up with a value close to Maximum but just a bit less so that you don't have the resize issue.

               

              HTH

              Bruce

              • 4. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
                smoothie

                Nope; if you tell it what size to make the new window, it still does it.

                • 5. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
                  MarcDolley

                  This is, and always has been the standard behaviour on Windows. It's not likely to change any time soon either. Your only option, as others have said, is to control the size of all of your windows. You'll find most people blame the Windows OS for the cause. Perhaps others can shed some light on the reasons.

                   

                  Regardless, there is nothing you can do about it. Now that you're aware of this behaviour, you can implement the same workarounds the rest of us have been doing for years. It's not that hard.

                   

                  Regards

                  Marc

                  • 6. Re: Undesirable Window Resizing Without Telling it To!
                    timwhisenant

                    Hi Smoothie,

                     

                    The point is not the new window, rather the main window, which you would seek maximized state. Instead of maximizing the window, you need to set it's size precisely.

                    I name this main window and refer to it by name in my "FullWindow" script.

                     

                    Try this, it works for me:

                    In your opening script give the main window a name of "Main" for instance.

                              Set Window Title[ name: "Main"]

                              Perform Script[ "FullWindow" ]

                     

                    the FullWindow script

                              Move/Resize Window( Name: "Main"; Current file; Height: Get( WindowDesktopHeight ) - 10; Width: Get( WindowDesktopWidth ) - 12; Top: 0; Left: 0 )

                              Exit Script [ ]

                     

                    I use a script so that any time I need to reinforce the main window I just call it.

                    Also it is easy to find and maintain any time a change is needed.

                     

                    HTH

                    Tim