7 Replies Latest reply on Apr 16, 2014 2:59 PM by Mike_Mitchell

    Drop-Down List Formatting


      All, I have a drop down list that only shows the second value, while storing the first (key field). however, the second value is only one charictor, while the key is a UUID. When I click the drop down list the id is selected and the list is down below it. it just looks funny, and I think it will confuse users. I have attached a screen shot of what it does. any suggestions?


      dropdown screen shot.jpg

        • 1. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

          In layout mode select the field; in the Inspector Data tab select "As Entered" in the Format dropdown in the Data Formatting area.

          • 2. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

            Thanks for the timp, I tried it, and unfortunalty the format dropdown is greyed out, I guess becuase the field typ that holds the UUID is a text field. Or am I missing something?

            • 3. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

              From your description (and screen shot), I'm not 100% sure what you have. I don't see a value list with only a series of single characters; I see a value list of what look like product codes. I think what you have is the product code ("cost code"?) as the second value, and the UUID (which looks like what's in the field) as the actual entered value?


              If that's correct, then this is the expected behavior. It's also, as you pointed out, a little confusing for the average user. I would also recommend against using this strategy without some additional safeguards (like validating the key field against the value list). It's never really a good idea to give users direct access to key fields in your database; the chances of damaging the relational setup are pretty high.


              Instead, I suggest presenting a list view of all options, then using scripting to store the selected value in the required field. Spawn a temporary window (or a popover) with the relevant choices. You can use variables as temporary storage; when the users pick the item they want, insert that value's key into the correct field in the child table.





              • 4. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

                This problem really effects all my dropdown lists.  and you are right, it exposes the ID to possible user entry, which of course I don't want.  I tried using a popup list on the field I originally  posted about and that works fine there because the will only be 5 values in the list.  but my select company list has 100 items at present, so a popup list isn't an option there.  I definatly need help and suggestions.



                • 5. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

                  A drop-down starts to be awkward after around 25 - 30 values. For any more than that, you really need to look at a list view approach. You can augment this approach by using a search utility to narrow the list (just program a Quick Search to take the user's input from a global field and narrow the list down).

                  • 6. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

                    Several options:


                    1. Present a (modal) dialog to choose the value from a portal or list, incl. type-ahead functionality (in FM13: a popover!).


                    Consider reversing the order of events: instead of selecting a value in the portal row which creates a related record, have the user choose a product in a dialog, then create the related record (only if a selection has actually been made). That would allow you to get rid of the spare portal row by disallowing "creation of related records via this relationship".


                    2. Instead of using the value list for name resolution, display the related product name field (the one the foreign key references) in the portal; format it as a button, where a click goes to a minimized version (1x1 px) of the actual foreign key field (positioned directly adjacent) to open the dropdown list; that should prevent your users from typing into the field, but lets them utilize type-ahead on the product name.

                    tigerdad wrote:

                    I definatly need help and suggestions.

                    What you definitely need is a better spellchecker.

                    • 7. Re: Drop-Down List Formatting

                      Yeah, kind of a bummer you can't use a different context for a popover. Stuck with a portal ...