Continue to sort as you are doing, but put a check mark only in the "ContestantID" field in the "Group By" box and see what happens.
I am able to get the results I need in Excel by using the Save As Excel from FM and the following procedure in Excel:
Put cursor on the 1st record
Go to Data View
Click on Subtotal
Set up the Subtotal as follows:
x Replace Current Subtotal
x Summary Data Below
Am I mistaken in thinking that I should be able to accomplish this using nothing more than FM Export, or am I asking too much fo FM?